Bishop Paul Hinder, head of the Apostolic Vicariate of Southern Arabia, told Catholic News Service March 28, "I have no confirmation that anything happened Good Friday" and added that the rumours appear to be untrue.

Father Uzhunnalil, an Indian, was kidnapped March 4 from the home for the aged and disabled run by the Missionaries of Charity in Aden, Yemen. Four Missionaries of Charity and 12 others were murdered in the attack.

Speaking from his office in Abu Dhabi in the United Arab Emirates, Bishop Hinder said it appeared that in late March a rumour began in India that militants connected to the so-called Islamic State group planned to crucify Father Uzhunnalil on Good Friday. The rumour spread around the world through social media.

Leaders of the Salesian order in India said March 21 that there was no evidence to support the reports and asked people to refrain from "spreading false rumours."

Rumours that the murder was carried out began to circulate after Austrian Cardinal Christoph Schonborn of Vienna mentioned Father Uzhunnalil in his homily at the Easter Vigil March 26. The next day, the Vienna archdiocesan website posted a piece quoting Bishop Hinder and Indian Salesians as saying there was no evidence the priest was killed; Cardinal Schonborn had spoken to church leaders in the region and believed "there is still hope."

Bishop Hinder told CNS March 28, "Nobody knows exactly what is happening." However, he said, "I have sufficient reason to doubt" the reports of Father Uzhunnalil's death.

The bishop refused to comment further, saying the situation is "too delicate."