"For me as a Christian I have only a few choices -- the other side is Islamic, I can't choose them," said a man identified only as Rami, 45, a worshipper at the Catholic basilica in Cairo's Heliopolis district.
Christians like Rami said they would support former Prime Minister Ahmed Shafiq or former Foreign Minister Amr Moussa, who also served as secretary-general of the Arab League for 10 years. With 90 percent of the votes tallied May 25, Shafiq seemed headed for a mid-June runoff with the Muslim Brotherhood's Mohammed Mursi.
In the days before the May 23-24 presidential election, Rami told Catholic News Service, "Even if Shafiq and Moussa are from the old regime, they offer security and freedom to live the way we want. Around our communities these are the choices, although there are some with the revolution who spent time on Tahrir Square and will go with (Hamdeen) Sabahi," a former opposition leader.
Father Sherif Nashef, assistant pastor at the Melkite Catholic Church of St. Cyril, also described a community forced into pragmatism at the ballot box.
"When people see a man like Shafiq in power they will feel comfortable. They feel their country is in safe hands," he said, summing up the grudging support for figures associated with Mubarak's regime, which suppressed political Islamism in an often-brutal manner.
"Shafiq may be supported by the army if he is in power; they will keep us safe," said a woman identified only as Ines, a 39-year old accountant attending the Maronite Catholic Church in Heliopolis.
"In the beginning we were with the revolution, but after all that has happened we are against. Nothing has changed for the better. Sabahi may be a good man and a secularist, but his ideas are too ambitious for Egypt right now," she said.
"Under Shafiq, at least we will be back as we were. That's enough," she told CNS.
Islamist political parties already hold about 65 percent of seats in Egypt's Parliament.
Similar sentiments were apparent in less well-off Christian areas such as Manshiyet Nasser, a hillside slum in eastern Cairo that is home to at least 30,000 mainly Coptic Orthodox.
There, despite some support for Sabahi -- who has made fighting poverty a key plank of his campaign -- voters polled by local media said Shafiq's secularist, strongman credentials made him the obvious choice.
For years, Christians have complained about discrimination when it comes to building places of worship and holding senior administrative positions. More recently, many have been rattled by a year of military rule marked by a series of seemingly sectarian clashes -- both in distant villages and Cairo -- and several church burnings.
These have added to more general fears of Islamists placing restrictions on modest dress and selling and consuming alcohol.