A real threat to humans

By  Scott Mair, Youth Speak News
  • January 8, 2010
I find the circumstances of my birth quite interesting in light of public efforts to pass Bill C-384. When I was born 15 weeks prematurely I weighed less than two pounds. I also had underdeveloped lungs and experienced extreme pain. To ease the pain, my doctors gave me morphine which I had a bad reaction to. I stopped breathing and my condition became critical. The doctors said I wouldn’t survive. If I did I would have a disability.

Fortunately, while I did acquire cerebral palsy, I did not die. I was nursed back to health by dedicated doctors and nurses.

Furthermore, while my disability has presented me with challenges, such as the inability to hand write, it wasn’t as overwhelming as the doctors had predicted. When I look back, I don’t dwell on my disability. Rather, I recall how lucky I am to be alive.

Sadly, it appears that advocates of legal euthanasia feel that life’s a curse and that I am better off dead.

Bill C-384, which is expected to come to a vote after Parliament reconvenes in March, will allow a person to euthanize or assist in the suicide of patients experiencing “severe physical or mental pain,” provided those patients submit two written requests for euthanasia while appearing to be lucid.  

But legalizing euthanasia will allow people, who feel that suffering or a disability make life worthless, to foist death upon the young and the disabled.

Unfortunately, not only is this situation possible, it’s already happening in some countries. In the Netherlands,  where euthanasia is legal, doctors are killing newborns when an infant’s suffering is as minor as having spina bifida, a correctable medical condition.

The Netherlands is also deciding whether it should be legal to euthanize newborns based upon “foreseeable suffering.” In other words, they’re debating whether it’s OK or not to kill a living baby if convinced the baby will have a meaningless life.

Some euthanasia advocates, most notably Australian bioethicist Peter Singer, support this notion. Singer says he wouldn’t hesitate to kill an infant if he felt it was “in the best interests of the infant and the family.” Considering that I experienced great pain when I was born it’s probable that Singer would have had the neonatal version of me euthanized.

My disability is a part of me, but I don’t feel that it’s a measure of my worth or that it detracts from my human dignity.

The same goes for everyone else. One of the best examples of how a disabled person has human worth is the now deceased Christopher Reeve. Despite being paralysed from the neck down after an accident, the man who portrayed Superman on the big screen did not see his life as “worthless.” Rather, he said his accident gave his life new meaning. He rose from the ashes as an advocate for those with spinal cord injuries. He’s proof that one’s suffering or physical capabilities do not determine human worth.

Far from harming just the old, euthanasia harms everyone regardless of age, capability or social status. I pray Bill C-384 will be defeated. The lives of the old, the young and the weak literally depend on it.

(Mair, 19, is a journalism student at Carleton University in Ottawa.)

Please support The Catholic Register

Unlike many media companies, The Catholic Register has never charged readers for access to the news and information on our website. We want to keep our award-winning journalism as widely available as possible. But we need your help.

For more than 125 years, The Register has been a trusted source of faith-based journalism. By making even a small donation you help ensure our future as an important voice in the Catholic Church. If you support the mission of Catholic journalism, please donate today. Thank you.

DONATE