Greg Erlandson, who is president of the Catholic Press Association and president and publisher of Our Sunday Visitor in Huntington, Ind., noted that the printed version of Catholic publications is still the most effective "push" medium -- that is, one that is sent to readers on a regular basis without readers having to take the initiative to visit a website or take any other positive action.
In Canada, Glen Argan of the Western Catholic Reporter, newspaper of the Diocese of Edmonton, Alberta, said a recent extensive readership study conducted by his newspaper showed the majority of respondents were not users of Internet-based media at all -- although that hasn't stopped his organization from having an active website for 15 years.
Some people, he said, have asked if in print he's building on "a burning platform." So far, he said, "it's only smoldering," and the readership study confirmed his belief that print continues to look good for the foreseeable future.
Along with other editors, Argan spoke of the ongoing call for religious education components in Catholic publications. An example of his response, he said, was a recent series of 30 articles he wrote on St. Francis de Sales' "Introduction to the Devout Life," a classic work on how all people are called to holiness regardless of their state in life.
Christopher Gunty, editor and associate publisher of The Catholic Review, newspaper of the Baltimore Archdiocese, said that following an 18-month strategic planning process the Review has just launched a reformatted, biweekly print version along with a redesigned website.
His organization is adding staff to enable them to have a more frequently updated website and other electronic media including social media such as Twitter and YouTube. The website is mobile-friendly and they're working on developing smartphone apps.
"We're adding (staff) to our newsroom because we know that content is what's going to drive this process forward," said Gunty, who also is CEO of the newspaper's parent publishing company, the Cathedral Foundation/CR Media.
The newspaper, while published less frequently, will have more pages and will focus more on the "why" of Catholic news, while the electronic media more speedily deliver the who, what, when and where of traditional news reporting.
For example, he said, the first issue of the newly designed print edition features a cover story, "Why Marriage?"
Meanwhile, the multiple frequency and formats of the other media will, he said, enable the organization "to reach multiple audiences." In addition to a Web editor, he now has a social media coordinator who can, for example, post an article on YouTube, then re-tweet a White House tweet with a link to the story and the tweet "What say you, Catholics?" to get a conversation going on a given topic.
Father Drew Christiansen, editor-in-chief of America magazine, said America is just submitting a strategic plan to its board of directors, which he expects will endorse America's being "a multimedia platform."
America has had an award-winning website for years, is on Kindle, working at being on Nook (both electronic book platforms) and expects to begin negotiating with Apple in time to have an app for next year's 50th anniversary of Vatican Council II which will have not only the conciliar documents but commentaries on them. He said that like all journals, America was hit hard by the recession but he is confident that it has come through and looks forward to a future that will be "more interactive with readers."
Penny Wiegert, immediate past president of the CPA and editor of The Observer, newspaper of the Diocese of Rockford, Ill., said she believes that there they have finally arrived at a point where even with their limited staff they can "marry our print product with our Web and video products." She said she thinks everyone in the Catholic press is working on that.
At The Observer, she said, they didn't "jump in" to new media but took time to do the job well, and she said she thinks they're successfully "meeting the needs of all our constituencies."
Now, she feels, is the time for the Catholic press in the U.S. to reach out to Catholic journalists across the globe and help them make the same kinds of transitions.
Everyone is facing financial hurdles, she said, and she believes the key to getting resources allocated for the Catholic media is to emphasize the fact that "it isn't just journalism, it's evangelization."
She said "it would be tragic" if Catholics didn't have an authoritative, official Catholic source in which to find accurate reporting about the news of the Catholic world. The mission of the Catholic press is "to reach and teach" Catholics everywhere, and every diocese has to discern how to support that mission.
"We just have to keep improving in order to fulfill our mission," which she said is challenging, rewarding and exhausting.
The CPA designates February as Catholic Press Month.
Wiegert said she is greatly encouraged by Erlandson's recent appointment to the Pontifical Council for Social Communications because that opens another avenue of communication between Catholic journalists and the world's Catholic bishops.
"This is a challenging business right now," Erlandson said, "because we're in the midst of so much change without clear signposts as to what direction we're going in."
He said he's convinced that print is still "viable and essential," of continuing importance because often the most avid readers are the most committed and active Catholics -- the ones most likely to contribute time, talent and treasure to the work of the church. If they had to depend on the general press for their information about what's going on in the Catholic world, they'd be getting "a very thin diet."
He also noted the importance of the Catholic press in adult faith formation -- a matter almost everyone agrees is of utmost importance but to which few resources are devoted.
It's critical, he said, to build on bishops' awareness that they need the voice offered them by the Catholic media. "It's essential for the church to communicate with its people," he said.