Archbishop Terrence Prendergast said he was surprised by the negative reaction to an artistic initiative after critics called the spider’s placement “sacrilegious,” “demonic,” and “disrespectful” of a sacred space.
“My cathedral staff and I anticipated that some few might object, but thought it would be minimal as nothing demeaning was intended in the spider being near the church,” said the archbishop in an email interview.
“I regret that we had not sufficiently understood that others would see this event so differently. I say to those who were shocked that I understand that this would have been upsetting for them and that I regret that a well-intentioned effort to cooperate in a celebration was anything but that for them.”
The spider, named Kumo, is one of two giant robots created by a street theatre company of artists, technicians and performers based in Nantes, France. The company, called La Machine, was in Ottawa July 27-30 as part of celebrations marking Canada’s 150th birthday.
The spectacle of robots, music and other special effects drew tens of thousands to Ottawa’s downtown.
The show opened July 27 in the evening, with Kumo “waking up” to organ music from inside the cathedral. As the spider, suspended from cranes, climbed off its perch between the towers, “snow” fell from above as part of the event’s special effects.
“I don’t understand how allowing a mechanical spider to stand on the cathedral is anything but disturbing, disappointing and even shameful,” wrote Diane Bartlett on the archbishop’s Facebook wall.
“How dare you profane a sacred house of God that houses the body and blood of our Lord inside it by putting a metallic arachnid on it of all things,” wrote Joe Recouso on Facebook. “It is totally irreverent and unacceptable. While our faith is slowly dying around us, it seems you decide to be part of the problem instead of the solution. I will pray you realize the errors of your ways and repent.”
A giant mechanical spider is seen during an art performance in front of Notre-Dame Cathedral Basilica in Ottawa July 27. (CNS photo/Chris Wattie, Reuters
While some objected to the pagan storyline around Kumo and Long Ma, others defended the archbishop’s decision.
“While the viewer may find the juxtaposition jarring, I gather it’s supposed to be,” wrote Kris Dmytrenko. “But sacrilegious? C’mon, give your archbishop a break. This civic engagement with art recalls the Vatican’s Courtyard of the Gentiles project. Culture is a bridge.”
The decision to participate in the show was motivated by a desire to engage with the wider Ottawa community, said archbishop Prendergast .
“We make use of the city to obtain permits for our events and they are most cooperative,” he said. “The Good Friday way-of-the cross lets us have access to public venues (Supreme Court, Parliament Hill, the plaza in front of the National Gallery) and the police offer a security escort.
“We try to be good citizens, good neighbours and cooperative,” he said.
“To the extent that we did see symbolism, it was that, afterwards, Our Lady would continue to reign, something I mentioned in a Tweet right after the Thursday performance as people I respect began to make their objections known.”
Organizers approached the cathedral staff last year. They wanted to position Kumo on the cathedral because it is across the street from the National Art Gallery, which features a large spider sculpture called Maman in its entrance courtyard, Archbishop Prendergast said. The idea was to make it seem as if Kumo was approaching Maman.
“Cathedral staff were shown other cathedrals and public buildings in Europe that had been involved,” the archbishop said. “It seemed innocent enough.
“I guess we thought people would see this as a sign the Church is involved in Ottawa’s celebrations. Many people, both Catholic and others, English and francophone, remarked how pleased they were that Notre Dame was involved in our celebration of Canada 150.
Many people supported the initiative, Prendergast said.
“They saw it as a wonderful way for people to get out into the fresh air and sunshine — we’ve been bearing with soggy weather all summer. Most children and their parents were delighted.”
Prendergast gave the show a good review.
“I was spellbound by the professionalism of the musical performance that accompanied the event on Thursday,” he said.
Although some people were offended by the pagan nature of the storyline, Prendergast said he doubted that “anyone following the events saw in it as anything but a fairy tale.”